Broll
ReplayVine & Vessel (Pty) Ltd · Shop 14
Workpaper →

Oakfield Mall, Sandton · Shop 14 · 142 m²

Vine & Vessel (Pty) Ltd

lease 2024-10-01 to 2029-09-30 · 8,00% each October

R6 546,40
recoverable · 5 of 48 lines · base rent · electricity
R3 856,00
25·09
25·10
25·11
25·12
26·01
26·02
26·03
26·04
26·05
26·06
26·07
26·08

Billed vs Permitted

Exceptions first · 48 lines · 12 periods
PeriodBasisBilledPermittedDeltaClause
Window totalR776 736,90R770 670,50+R6 066,40
2025-0948200.00 (no escalation yet)R52 056,00R48 200,00+R3 856,00cl. 4
2026-011180.00 kWh × 2.8500 R/kWh (tariff CoJ-BUS-2026)R4 035,60R3 363,00+R672,60cl. 7
2026-021180.00 kWh × 2.8500 R/kWh (tariff CoJ-BUS-2026)R4 035,60R3 363,00+R672,60cl. 7
2026-031180.00 kWh × 2.8500 R/kWh (tariff CoJ-BUS-2026)R4 035,60R3 363,00+R672,60cl. 7
2026-041180.00 kWh × 2.8500 R/kWh (tariff CoJ-BUS-2026)R4 035,60R3 363,00+R672,60cl. 7
2026-071380.00 kWh × 3.0500 R/kWh (tariff CoJ-BUS-2026)R3 933,00R4 209,00R-276,00cl. 7
2026-081020.00 kWh × 3.0500 R/kWh (tariff CoJ-BUS-2026)R2 907,00R3 111,00R-204,00cl. 7
2025-09 to 2026-08 · 41 lines · billed matches permittedShow lines
2025-091150.00 kWh × 2.8500 R/kWh (tariff CoJ-BUS-2026)R3 277,50R3 277,50R0,00cl. 7
2025-096150.00 monthly recoveryR6 150,00R6 150,00R0,00cl. 6
2025-092980.00 monthly recoveryR2 980,00R2 980,00R0,00cl. 8
2025-1048200.00 × 1.08^1 (esc Oct, 8%)R52 056,00R52 056,00R0,00cl. 4
2025-10980.00 kWh × 2.8500 R/kWh (tariff CoJ-BUS-2026)R2 793,00R2 793,00R0,00cl. 7
2025-106150.00 monthly recoveryR6 150,00R6 150,00R0,00cl. 6
2025-102980.00 monthly recoveryR2 980,00R2 980,00R0,00cl. 8
2025-1148200.00 × 1.08^1 (esc Oct, 8%)R52 056,00R52 056,00R0,00cl. 4
2025-111320.00 kWh × 2.8500 R/kWh (tariff CoJ-BUS-2026)R3 762,00R3 762,00R0,00cl. 7
2025-116150.00 monthly recoveryR6 150,00R6 150,00R0,00cl. 6
2025-112980.00 monthly recoveryR2 980,00R2 980,00R0,00cl. 8
2025-1248200.00 × 1.08^1 (esc Oct, 8%)R52 056,00R52 056,00R0,00cl. 4
2025-121050.00 kWh × 2.8500 R/kWh (tariff CoJ-BUS-2026)R2 992,50R2 992,50R0,00cl. 7
2025-126150.00 monthly recoveryR6 150,00R6 150,00R0,00cl. 6
2025-122980.00 monthly recoveryR2 980,00R2 980,00R0,00cl. 8
2026-0148200.00 × 1.08^1 (esc Oct, 8%)R52 056,00R52 056,00R0,00cl. 4
2026-016150.00 monthly recoveryR6 150,00R6 150,00R0,00cl. 6
2026-012980.00 monthly recoveryR2 980,00R2 980,00R0,00cl. 8
2026-0248200.00 × 1.08^1 (esc Oct, 8%)R52 056,00R52 056,00R0,00cl. 4
2026-026150.00 monthly recoveryR6 150,00R6 150,00R0,00cl. 6
2026-022980.00 monthly recoveryR2 980,00R2 980,00R0,00cl. 8
2026-0348200.00 × 1.08^1 (esc Oct, 8%)R52 056,00R52 056,00R0,00cl. 4
2026-036150.00 monthly recoveryR6 150,00R6 150,00R0,00cl. 6
2026-032980.00 monthly recoveryR2 980,00R2 980,00R0,00cl. 8
2026-0448200.00 × 1.08^1 (esc Oct, 8%)R52 056,00R52 056,00R0,00cl. 4
2026-046150.00 monthly recoveryR6 150,00R6 150,00R0,00cl. 6
2026-042980.00 monthly recoveryR2 980,00R2 980,00R0,00cl. 8
2026-0548200.00 × 1.08^1 (esc Oct, 8%)R52 056,00R52 056,00R0,00cl. 4
2026-051250.00 kWh × 2.8500 R/kWh (tariff CoJ-BUS-2026)R3 562,50R3 562,50R0,00cl. 7
2026-056150.00 monthly recoveryR6 150,00R6 150,00R0,00cl. 6
2026-052980.00 monthly recoveryR2 980,00R2 980,00R0,00cl. 8
2026-0648200.00 × 1.08^1 (esc Oct, 8%)R52 056,00R52 056,00R0,00cl. 4
2026-061100.00 kWh × 2.8500 R/kWh (tariff CoJ-BUS-2026)R3 135,00R3 135,00R0,00cl. 7
2026-066150.00 monthly recoveryR6 150,00R6 150,00R0,00cl. 6
2026-062980.00 monthly recoveryR2 980,00R2 980,00R0,00cl. 8
2026-0748200.00 × 1.08^1 (esc Oct, 8%)R52 056,00R52 056,00R0,00cl. 4
2026-076150.00 monthly recoveryR6 150,00R6 150,00R0,00cl. 6
2026-072980.00 monthly recoveryR2 980,00R2 980,00R0,00cl. 8
2026-0848200.00 × 1.08^1 (esc Oct, 8%)R52 056,00R52 056,00R0,00cl. 4
2026-086150.00 monthly recoveryR6 150,00R6 150,00R0,00cl. 6
2026-082980.00 monthly recoveryR2 980,00R2 980,00R0,00cl. 8

Findings

Finding
Clause
Delta
Standing
Renewal window approaching
File health · Medium · The renewal/option notice must be given by 2026-11-30 (89 days away).
cl. 11
R0,00
note
Base rent does not match lease amount
Contractual · High · 2025-09 · Billed R52056.00 vs permitted R48200.00 (delta R3856.00) — escalation applied one month early; billed the post-step amount before the anniversary
defensible
Electricity charge exceeds approved tariff cap
Provable — electricity · High · 2026-01 to 2026-04 (4 periods) · Billed 3.4200 R/kWh vs cap 2.8500 R/kWh; delta = R672.60, recoverable with interest
provable
Electricity under-recovered vs approved tariff
Ledger only · Low · 2026-07 · Billed 2.8500 R/kWh vs approved 3.0500 R/kWh; R276.00 under-recovered this period
note
Electricity under-recovered vs approved tariff
Ledger only · Low · 2026-08 · Billed 2.8500 R/kWh vs approved 3.0500 R/kWh; R204.00 under-recovered this period
note